The Limits of Reason

Originally published on casperanwar.com
At the basis of traditional finance theories is the assumption that people are consistently rational. However, this is far from the truth. Here's one quick story to illustrate.
In 1997, Richard Thaler, the (2017) Nobel Prize winner in Economics conducted an experiment. He placed an ad in the Financial Times inviting people to play a simple game...
Thaler asked readers to choose a number between 0 and 100. The person whose number was the closest to two thirds of the average of all guesses would be the winner.
What number would you choose?
What would be the best choice?
Logically, the best choice would be 0.
If all guesses average to 50, then 33 is actually the best guess as it is two thirds of this average. Thus, a lot of people might decide intuitively to choose 33 instead of 50. However, that will make 22 the best guess.
So, if you carry this through to its logical end, you’ll eventually see that 0 is the optimal answer.
If we lived in a world where people consistently used information rationally and optimally, everybody would choose 0. Of course, that didn’t happen in Thaler's experiment. The average of all guesses was 18.9, with the winning entry being 13.
In Forecast by Mark Buchanan, he questions if absolute rationality can exist at all. When we carry a supposedly “rational” process through to its logical conclusion, we see an absurd chain of events that reveals rationality to be an illusion.
Let’s say that a fund you’ve invested in is crashing, and you’re thinking of selling it. But before making a decision (and without being emotional), you have to carry out research and gather information, so that you’ll ultimately be able to take the best course of action: to sell or not.
Most investors know that trying to time the market is contrary to achieving their long-term goals, but knowing that to be true doesn't necessarily keep you from making the wrong decisions when markets are slumping.
If you were fully rational, you’d spend the optimal amount of time on research and then make a decision. But how can you possibly know what that amount of time is? To determine it, you’d have to decide how much time to spend on thinking about the optimal amount of time for research – which presents the problem of how much time you should take for that step. Absurd, right?
Countless experiments show humans as incapable of making the right decisions. We are emotional, myopic, and easily confused. Even if we are capable of being rational, we certainly don’t behave rationally all the time.
Maybe it's impossible to be completely rational about making financial decisions?
Maybe the point here is that the choice isn’t between making a rational or irrational decision, but rather a question about how best to manage the tensions between these two forces?
Maybe recognising when you are not being as rational as you can be might help you slow down. The more time you take, the less likely you are to make a bad decision.
Casper



